Rogue Ohio Bar vs. Rogue Echo Bar
If you’re someone who is looking for a multi-use barbell, Rogue offers two solid choices in the Ohio and the Echo 2.0. Because of their high quality builds, Rogue’s barbells tend to be a hot commodity for those building out their home gyms. When choosing a barbell, these are two good contenders because they can be used for compound lifts such as deadlifts and squats, and also provide the spin needed to perform a power clean. While the Ohio Bar may get a lot of attention as far as Rogue products go, the Echo Bar 2.0 is also a fierce contender.
While they aren’t identical, they do in fact share a lot of the same qualities that will make either one of these a great addition to your home gym stock. Because of the bronze bushings on the sleeves of these barbells, you can successfully perform CrossFit and Olympic style lifts, while also working on your powerlifting.
Both bars feature the same Volcano style knurling pattern, and the overall grip is moderate — not too abrasive while still offering a firm handle on your equipment. All of that being said, there are a few differences that jumped out at us. The Echo 2.0 is significantly cheaper than the Ohio, and each bar is made using different materials. But let’s take a closer look at these two popular barbells from Rogue.
- Rogue Ohio Bar Highlights
- Rogue Echo Bar Highlights
- What Are the Big Differences Between the Rogue Ohio Bar and the Rogue Echo Bar?
- Which Barbell is the Better Option?
- Is Stainless Steel That Much Better Than Zinc?
- Can the Ohio Do Anything the Echo 2.0 Can’t?
- Final Word
Rogue Ohio Bar Highlights
A true stud in the weight room, the Ohio Bar is similar to a Swiss army knife in that it allows you to hit nearly any workout imaginable. While it does come in a few different options, the version we will be discussing is stainless steel. Stainless steel is the best material you could ask for in terms of fighting off corrosion, especially if you live in a humid area — plus it offers a high tensile strength. The other options you can choose from are coated in black zinc, black oxide, an e-coat, or you can select the custom bar and get the coating of your choice, among other customizations.
If you are interested in spending time doing movements such as power cleans or the snatch, you will appreciate that the Ohio bar does not have a center knurling. This will cause less irritation to the skin from repeated use, however, you may miss out on an extra grip for your back squats.
Grooves in the loading sleeves may help keep your weight plates or bumper plates secured without the need for a weight collar. The bronze bushings allow the sleeves to spin, reducing the amount of torque on your wrists and elbows. And since the tensile strength is rated at 200,000 pounds (190,000 for the other coated options), it can handle heavy weight from elite level weightlifters.
Rogue Ohio Bar BarbellMira TambiénRogue Echo Bar 2.0 Barbell Review
Rogue Ohio Bar Barbell
The Rogue Ohio Bar is 28mm in diameter, has a sleeve length of 16.4 inches, and features two knurling marks for optimal hand placement. It$0027s made of stainless steel, and comes with a lifetime warranty.
- The Ohio is available in stainless steel, providing the highest resistance to rust and corrosion.
- Since there is no center knurl, the chances of your skin becoming irritated during Olympic and CrossFit style lifts is significantly less than you would find from a bar with a center knurl.
- The stainless steel Ohio has a tensile strength of 200,000 PSI, which puts it in the higher tier of barbells since the max is 230,000 PSI.
Rogue Echo Bar Highlights
Similar to the Ohio, the Echo 2.0 is also a multi-purpose barbell that you can use for your powerlifting, Olympic, or CrossFit style lifts. Plus, it’s also able to handle some pretty heavy weights itself. The loading sleeves on this bar also feature bronze bushings that provide the required spin for lifts like power cleans, and are grooved to help keep your plates in place.
The abrasiveness of the knurling is also on the moderate side, and features the same Volcano pattern as the Ohio. Although, the stainless steel Ohio may have a better feel in your hands, since there isn’t an extra layer of material coating the bar. Unlike the Ohio, the Echo 2.0 only comes in a regular zinc finish — this is still going to provide resistance to corrosion, but not as effectively as stainless steel. The lack of a center knurling on this bar also makes it a good option for power cleans, but similar to the Ohio, you may miss out on the extra grip for your back squats.
The 190,000 pound tensile strength rating is less than the stainless steel Ohio, but is equal to the other Ohio options, and the Echo is available at a more reasonable price. Since this bar is able to compete with top tier bars like the Ohio, it may actually be one of the biggest steals out there.Mira TambiénWatch Chris Bumstead Forge His Pecs With Heavy Presses and Volume Training
Rogue Echo 2.0
Rogue Echo 2.0
The Echo 2.0 is one of Rogue$0027s most affordable barbells. This multi-purpose bar offers high functionality and versatility, the utilization of bronze bushings create a controlled spin, and the lack of a center knurl makes it ideal for Olympic and CrossFit lifts.
Shop Rogue Fitness
- The 190,000 PSI tensile strength rating of the Echo 2.0 means it can handle heavy weight in the gym — though Rogue doesn’t specifically say, most bars with this tensile strength can support up to 1,000 pounds.
- The combination of bronze bushings and no center knurl make it a good choice for both Olympic and CrossFit style lifts.
- The Volcano style knurling is a medium grade, so it won’t tear up your hands, but should still provide a solid grip.
What Are the Big Differences Between the Rogue Ohio Bar and the Rogue Echo Bar?
While both of these all-around barbells from Rogue are fairly similar, there are a few differences. From the pricing to the finish and overall strength, here’s what separates the Ohio from the Echo 2.0.
Stainless Steel vs. Zinc
These two barbells look fairly similar, but are crafted using different materials. While the Echo 2.0 only comes with a regular zinc finish, the Ohio is available in multiple finishes.Mira TambiénJulius Maddox Bench Presses New PR of 361 Kilograms (796 Pounds) Raw in Training
The Ohio bar we used is crafted with stainless steel, the best material in terms of fighting off rust and corrosion — plus it doesn’t need to be cared for as much as a bar with a coated material. The stainless steel Ohio features chrome sleeves, but you can also opt for them to be fully stainless steel. This is an extra fee, but a fully stainless steel bar is the most durable, in our opinion.
The Rogue Echo 2.0 that we got our hands on is forged with steel, and coated in regular zinc. This zinc gives the bar a nice shine, and offers a decent amount of protection against corrosion, but not as much as stainless steel can. So if you live in a humid environment, you may want to invest in a care kit for your barbell, so it can stay in prime condition. While the Echo 2.0 feels pretty "grippy" in your hands, the zinc may not provide the same grip that the stainless steel can. In our workouts with both of these barbells, the Ohio seemed to have a better overall grip as our hands began to sweat.
There’s a Price Difference
The price difference between these two barbells is pretty significant. This could be due to the higher tensile strength rating and protection from corrosion you get with the fully stainless steel Ohio bar, but the stainless steel Ohio is listed at $370, while the Echo 2.0 is $270.
Rogue Ohio Bar
The stainless steel Ohio that we tested is listed at $370 on the Rogue Fitness website. If you wanted the stainless steel sleeves, those are going to be an extra $95, and once you factor in shipping, you’re looking at spending over $500. $500 is a lot of money, but the overall caliber of this bar may make it worth the price tag. And while this is a pretty pricey barbell, there are actually some barbells out there that are around $800.
If you’re interested in the other Ohio Bar options, the black zinc and e-coat bars are priced around $305, the black oxide will cost you about $320, and the custom bar is nearly $350. These prices aren’t too far off from the stainless steel bar, so it may be worth spending a little bit more money for that extra protection, and tensile strength. It is worth mentioning that Rogue does allow you to purchase your barbell through PayLater from PayPal, and through Affirm — splitting your purchase up into four interest-free payments of around $130.
Rogue Echo 2.0
It doesn’t take long to realize that the Echo 2.0 is the way to go if you are on a tight budget. Priced at $270, shipping and taxes are going to put you right around $315 in total. Even compared to the cheaper versions of the Ohio, you are still going to be saving money with this barbell. The utilization of PayLater and Affirm will put your four interest-free payments right around $80.
While you may need to lubricate your bar to prevent corrosion, the overall quality and tensile strength rating make this barbell well worth $300 in our eyes. We do realize that is still a decent amount of money, but compared to a lot of barbells at that price, which are often made from lesser materials and may feature a tensile strength that is closer to 120,000 PSI — this may be an absolute steal.Mira TambiénCheck Out Shaun Clarida’s High Volume Quad Training To Improve His Front-Facing Poses
Tensile strength is one of our determining factors when choosing a barbell. In short, this is how much weight and force a barbell can endure before it begins to bend or break. The Echo 2.0 has a tensile strength rating of 190,000 PSI. This number is identical to all of the Ohio options other than the stainless steel, which has a rating of 200,000 PSI.
Both of these barbells are relatively close to the max threshold of 230,000 PSI. Obviously the stainless steel Ohio is rated higher, but 10,000 PSI may not be enough for some people to spend significantly more money. Oftentimes, you’ll find that barbells with a price tag similar to the Echo 2.0, are made from cheaper materials, and may even feature a much lower tensile strength. Both the Echo 2.0, and the Ohio are good options for beginners to grow with, but they’re also able to support the needs of an experienced lifter.
The utilization of bronze bushings in the loading sleeves of both of these barbells allow them to spin, and contribute to their ability to be used in a multitude of ways. Bronze bushings may not spin at the same rate as bearings, but they degrade slower, and are also cheaper. In our time with both of these Rogue barbells, the sleeves spun at the same rate — despite one on the Echo 2.0 that kept going like a runaway freight train. We aren’t sure why that was the case, and it may be in only our specific bar, but it’s something worth mentioning.
The overall knurling on both of these barbells was extremely similar. They’re both on the moderate side, which is ideal for barbells you’re using for varying styles of lifts. They also both feature a Volcano style grip. Each marking on the knurling dips in like a volcano does, offering four points of contact for your hand at each marking, which may be the best grip you could ask for — especially when you compare it to a mountain grip knurling that only offers one point of contact for each marking.
However, in our time with these two barbells, it was hard to ignore the fact that the Ohio seemed to have a better overall feel in our hands. While the Echo 2.0 does have a solid grip, as our hands began to sweat, our grip felt a tad bit more compromised than it did with the Ohio.
It’s not that the Ohio is cut deeper, but rather, it is most likely due to the fact that the Echo 2.0 has that extra layer on the bar from the zinc coating — something that is not there with the stainless steel Ohio. The coated options of the Ohio may be similar to the Echo 2.0 in how they perform during workouts though — we were just not able to test this theory firsthand.
Another feature that jumped out right away is that the Echo 2.0 does not have double knurl markings like the Ohio Bar does. Double knurl markings are pretty common in barbells like these, since they allow you to accurately achieve both the closest, and widest grip possible during your lifts. This may make it a little more challenging to get an identical grip for your lifts on the Echo, but it’s likely not a make or break.
While the weight capacity of these barbells are not listed on the Rogue website, it’s safe to say that the stainless steel Ohio can hold more weight due to its higher tensile strength rating. This is something that powerlifters may want to consider when deciding between these two bars.
Based on their tensile strength, the Echo 2.0, and the coated options of the Ohio will most likely cap out around 1,000 pounds. But since the stainless steel Ohio has a tensile strength rating of 200,000 pounds, you’re looking at a max weight closer to 1,200 pounds. This may not affect all athletes, but elite lifters will want to consider that when choosing between these two bars.
We were a bit surprised to find that the Echo 2.0 does not come with a lifetime warranty like the Ohio Bar. This is most likely due to the lower tensile strength, and its zinc coating. The combination of the two may have you looking for a new barbell sooner than you would with the Ohio.
Which Barbell is the Better Option?
Neither of these Rogue barbells is perfect — since they both have their pros and cons, your decision should be made on personal preference. Some questions you may want to ask yourself could be about cost, materials used, and overall strength. Whichever is a priority to you should be your driving factor.
While the stainless steel Ohio Bar is the most expensive option, it’s also going to accommodate more for those of elite strength. Plus, it will potentially last you longer since it can fight off corrosion at a higher rate.
If you’re interested in saving money, the Echo 2.0 is going to be your best bet. Priced around $270, you’re going to be saving around $200 compared to the fully stainless steel Ohio, and it’s also cheaper than the coated Ohio options. That extra money can go into filling out your home gym with some weight plates, a power rack, squat rack, or maybe even a new set of dumbbells.
With a tensile strength rating that isn’t too far off from the Ohio, it makes a whole lot of sense to snag the Echo 2.0 since you will most likely get the same usage out of it. But since it’s coated in zinc, it won’t give you the same level of protection as the stainless steel Ohio can, so you will need to use some lubricant to keep it in good condition, or else you may be in the market for a new barbell sooner than you’d hoped.
The best part about these barbells is that they offer the ability to perform a wide variety of workouts. You can easily practice your clean and jerk or snatch, or load up the bar for a heavy bench press. The bronze bushings featured in the sleeves of these bars make it possible to switch up your workouts, but won’t spin uncontrollably. At the end of the day, these two barbells are fairly similar, so you need to focus on which of these features is best for your goals, and your pockets, and that will help you find the "best" option for you.
Is Stainless Steel That Much Better Than Zinc?
Yes, stainless steel is the absolute king when it comes to fighting off rust and corrosion. A regular zinc finish is still going to provide some protection, but not as much as stainless steel can. With any expensive product, the goal is to have it last as long as possible, right? With the stainless steel Ohio, you are going to have a higher chance of keeping your barbell in your hands, and providing that pump for 20+ years.
Stainless steel is the optimal choice for those who are living in a humid environment specifically. When it comes to the regular zinc — like you’ll find in the Echo — you’ll need to perform more upkeep in order to keep the finish (especially in humid environments), which is why the Ohio bar takes the W for us here.
Can the Ohio Do Anything the Echo 2.0 Can’t?
Despite the higher tensile strength rating, both of these barbells offer you the ability to hit similar workouts. They both have moderate knurling, and bronze bushings on the sleeves. They can easily handle most lifts (aside from exercises like squats where you may want a center knurl), with the only difference being how much weight they can hold. While the Echo 2.0 likely has the same max loadable weight as the coated Ohio options, the stainless steel Ohio can handle the most weight due to its higher tensile strength.
Before you make a decision on one of these Rogue barbells, you need to weigh the pros and cons of both. If you are working with a large budget, and are loading on super heavy weight, you may find the stainless steel Ohio Bar is the one for you. However, if you are on a tighter budget, the Echo 2.0 may be your best bet as it can handle the same style of workouts as the Ohio, while also holding a decent amount of weight itself, and costing significantly less.
If you’re interested in a lifetime warranty, the Ohio Bar has you covered, while the Echo only offers a one-year warranty. This may be because the zinc coating on the Echo 2.0 is likely not as durable as the stainless steel on the Ohio — though when it comes down to it, both should last you for many years.
The beauty of both of these barbells is that they can truly service those who are just beginning their weightlifting journey, as well as seasoned vets. We do believe the stainless steel Ohio Bar is the superior barbell — we just can’t pass up on the extra grip the stainless steel provides, or the added protection from corrosion. But if you’re tight on budget, the Echo 2.0 is still a great choice.
Deja una respuesta
►Te puede interesar...